Study finds 9pm shop-closing rule cuts retail transactions by 42%

“An Ipsos study found the 9pm shop-closing rule reduced average daily retail transactions by 42%, while only 41% of retailers reported lower utility bills.”
Key points
- An Ipsos study found the 9pm shop-closing rule reduced average daily retail transactions by 42%, while only 41% of retailers reported lower utility bills.
- The rule remains in force in Punjab, Islamabad and Balochistan, while Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa ended it in May.
A study presented by the Chainstore Association of Pakistan has found that the 9pm shop-closing rule reduced daily retail transactions by 42%, while evidence of meaningful energy savings remained limited. The research, conducted by Ipsos, examined the impact of the policy on retailers and consumers in areas where the restriction remains in force.
Retailers reported that average daily operating time declined by 1.6 hours, falling from 11.2 hours to 9.6 hours. Across 10 major product categories, the average number of daily transactions per outlet dropped from 86 to 50. Footwear retailers reported one of the sharpest declines, with transactions falling from 85 to 38 a day.
The study found that the proportion of retailers describing their sales as good fell from 79% before the rule to 34% after its implementation. The share reporting high profitability also declined from 67% to 26%. Retailers said evening business was particularly affected, with the share reporting heavy footfall between 4pm and 8pm falling from 63% to 32%.
The policy was introduced as an energy-conservation measure, but only 41% of retailers surveyed reported lower utility bills. In Punjab, Islamabad and Balochistan, where the 9pm restriction still applies, that figure was 31%. Even retailers who believed the rule had supported energy savings said their average daily transactions had fallen sharply.
Among 300 retailers surveyed, half opposed the current rule and 32% supported it. Opposition was higher among business owners, at 54%. Of retailers who believed the policy had achieved its energy objective, only one in five wanted it to continue without change, while most preferred revised timings or removal of the restriction.
Businesses have adjusted their operations in response. About 73% said they now open earlier, 34% had started or expanded online selling, and 12% had reduced staff. The study cautioned, however, that a shift to digital channels does not necessarily replace lost evening customers for all retail segments.
Consumers were also divided. Of 1,046 respondents, 35% supported early closing, 33% were neutral and 32% opposed it. More than half said finding time to shop had become harder, while 37% said their shopping experience had worsened. Women reported a larger decline in monthly shopping trips than men.
The research compared practices across 15 countries and found that Bangladesh was the only other market using early shop closures as an energy-saving tool. Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa lifted the restriction on May 16, 2026, while the rule continues in Punjab, Islamabad and Balochistan.
Corrections & clarifications
Spot an inaccuracy or need more detail? Email connect@newsnexus24.com. Publication time is shown above.





